The Victims The Place Time It Was The Crime The Investigation The Convicted
The Victims The Place Time it was The Investigation The Crime The Convicted

Anthony Hollingsworth, recent 
Anthony Hollingsworth, recent.

A Twilight Kill, Part Four: The Compromised.

    In spite of the obsession of some officials, there was very little to connect Echols to the crime. One intriguing bit of evidence came from Narlene Hollingsworth and her family who gave statements that on the night of the disappearance they drove past Echols who was walking with his girlfriend, Domini Teer, not far from where the bodies were discovered.

    Narlene Hollingsworth played multiple roles in the case, claiming she had a conversation with the victims shortly before they disappeared and providing an alibi for one of the accused. She was the mother of one potential suspect and the aunt of another.

    At about 9:30 pm, Narlene loaded up her station wagon with family. While approaching the Blue Beacon Truck Wash, she and several family members said she saw her niece, Domini, and Damien Echols walking together alongside the Service Road.

    Narlene would testify this occurred on May fifth, the night the children disappeared but also said that it happened two days before she gave her statement on the tenth. Her son, Anthony, would also testify and have trouble with the date.

Davidson: When did you say you went and talked with the police about this?
Anthony: Very next day. [Anthony Hollingsworth testimony, Echols/Baldwin trial]

    After being presented with his signed statement dated May 25th, 1993, Anthony changed his time frame.

Davidson: May the 25th is when you talked to 'em?
Anthony: Yes. [ibid]

    The presence of Damien and Domini on the Service Road a short distance from where the bodies were found represented a problem for the prosecution. Domini was not being presented as part of the crime and her alibi was solid for the time she was supposedly seen on the road. The prosecution put forth that the Hollingsworths mistook defendant Jason Baldwin for Domini.

    Baldwin's attorney, Paul Ford, protested the claim of misidentification.

Ford: Your Honor, we're asking for that instruction. This witness identified Damien and Domini at the roadside. There is no testimony whatsoever from either of these last two witnesses that Jason was there and the - you know good and well that the state is going to argue that she's wrong and that she is really seeing Jason and that's speculation, that's -
Judge David Burnett: I don't know, I'm just saying that -
Ford: - Just junk and what you're doing, Judge, is you're allowing them to do that. [Hollingsworth testimony, Echols/Baldwin trial]

    Narlene was adamant about who she saw. ''I wouldn't change my story if I was dying,'' said Hollingsworth, a resident of the Lakeshore Estates trailer park. ''I know that freckled-faced, red-headed girl anywhere.  It was Domini - not a boy." [Memphis Commercial Appeal, September 28, 1993]

Domini versus Jason    Jason Baldwin
The prosecution contended the Hollingsworth family mistook Jason (right) for Domini (left).

A Compromising Past

    Anthony Hollingsworth had a dark secret, he had been arrested for unlawful carnal knowledge with a minor. The defense attempted to bring this out, as a potential reason why he and Narlene might want to point to someone else as the killer. Narlene Hollingsworth testified, "He [Anthony] lives in a camper...He eats with me but he stays in the camper. He has to."
[Narlene Hollingsworth testimony, Echols/Baldwin trial]

The defense was not allowed to pursue the reason why, with the judge offering grounds for objection.

Judge Burnett: Are you objecting to relevancy?
Prosecutor Fogleman: I'm objecting to the relevancy.
Burnett:  Sustained. [ibid]

    Was Anthony a viable suspect? In spite of living far from the victims, Narlene recounted a connection to the Hobbs family. Sombra Joy was present in the car with Anthony and Narlene. Regarding a roadtrip earlier in the day, Narlene recalled, "[Sombra] said, 'Oh, I know them.' I said, 'You don't know them, they live over here and we way over there [snip]' She said, 'No, I really do, that's Steve Branch, I play with him everyday.'" [Narlene Hollingsworth statement] Narlene recalled being told the victims were missing at 6:30 pm, hours even before all of the victims' family were aware.

The self-appointed detective.

    Victoria Hutchison was at the police station charged with writing bad checks when she heard of the discovery of the victims. She took it upon herself to investigate the murders. "She said she was trying to play detective because she had heard that Damien was involved in devil worship and she thought it might be connected to the murders." [June 2nd, Victoria Hutchison, police notes.]

Prosecutor Fogleman:  Did you do any particular things to try to gain Damien’s confidence?
Hutchison:  I had went to the library. Don Bray, the police [chief] at Marion, had given me his card to check out some satanic books because they can’t be checked out just by normal - 
Fogelman:  All right. [Victoria Hutchison testimony, Misskelley trial]

    Unfortunately, the prosecutor interrupted her before allowing her to explain what she meant by this bizarre assertion.

    Eventually her investigations would involve wearing a wire and trying to attend cult meetings. She would give various and contradictory accounts of what happened there and would be the only witness to testify to the existence of the cult. In spite of her claim to have become close to Damien to infiltrate the cult, she said she never encountered Jason Baldwin.

    While Victoria Hutchison's detective escapades made for an interesting sideshow, her eight year old son took center stage. Aaron underwent a series of bizarre police interviews, each becoming more elaborate than the last. In spite of the fact that the statements negated one another and contradicted his mother's early assertions he was at home the afternoon and evening of the murders, he was brought back for more interviews up until the time of the trials.

    In his first statement to the police, dated May tenth, Aaron said he witnessed one of the victims being abducted by a black man in a maroon car. In a June 2nd interview he said he witnessed the murders by unknown attackers. After the three teenagers were arrested, he identified the accused as the killers. In subsequent statements he said that he was forced to take part in the murders and, on another occasion, stated he witnessed Mark Byers help murder the children. He was placed on the witness list for the prosecution, but not called to testify. 

    Victoria Hutchison later recanted her testimony, saying that she had not been to a cult meeting and probably just slept the night drunk on her lawn. She has apologized for her role in the affair. 

Aaron Hutcheson leading Victoria and police to crime scene
Aaron Hutchison leading his mother, Victoria, and police to the crime scene.

Continued in, A Twilight Kill, Part Five:  Return of the Moon.

Copyright © 2009 Martin David Hill
Site Design By Michael Gillen